CO129-260 - Governor Sir Robinson Acting Governor O-Brien - 1893 [9-12] — Page 114

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

a mastery of which is pre-supposed in the school books used in this college, virtually sealed mysteries to these Chinese boys. An attempt has lately been made to introduce an Anglo-Chinese conversational phrase book - compiled by one of the masters. The idea deserves the highest praise, but vocabulary phrases are here put together in a haphazard sort of way, there being no attempt made to lead the scholars inductively, as Hamilton, Prendergast or even Ollendorff do, from particular instances to general rules, so as to enable the scholar to gather for himself the rules (of accidence or syntax) from concrete examples.

Page 113

(3) Again, the new world of speech and thought into which Chinese boys are plunged in this School is not sufficiently linked with that Chinese old-world life from which these boys emerge - passing from a three years' course of purely Chinese schooling into this English college.

(4) Owing to the total and incomprehensible absence of object-lessons, the Chinese boys are throughout the School taught to read and write English before they are taught to speak English, to learn words before they learn the things denoted by those words.

(5) But a fundamental hindrance to progress, ... that

Edit History

2026-05-27 04:10:09 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
a mastery of which is pre-supposed in the school books used in this college, virtually sealed mysteries to these Chinese boys. An attempt has lately been made to introduce an Anglo-Chinese conversational phrase book - compiled by one of the masters. The idea deserves the highest praise, but vocabulary phrases are here put together in a haphazard sort of way, there being no attempt made to lead the scholars inductively, as Hamilton, Prendergast or even Ollendorff do, from particular instances to general rules, so as to enable the scholar to gather for himself the rules (of accidence or syntax) from concrete examples. Page 113 (3) Again, the new world of speech and thought into which Chinese boys are plunged in this School is not sufficiently linked with that Chinese old-world life from which these boys emerge - passing from a three years' course of purely Chinese schooling into this English college. (4) Owing to the total and incomprehensible absence of object-lessons, the Chinese boys are throughout the School taught to read and write English before they are taught to speak English, to learn words before they learn the things denoted by those words. (5) But a fundamental hindrance to progress, ... that
Baseline (Original)
a mastery of which is pre- supposed in the school books rain remar used in this bollege, virtually sealed mysteries to these Chinese boys. An attempt has lately been made to introduce an and Anglo-Chinese conversational phrase book- compiled by one of the masters. The idea deserves the highest praise, but vocabulary phrases are here pect to - her in a haphaz gether bort of way, there being attempt made to lead in the scholars, inductively, Hamilton, Prendergast or even Ollendorff do, from particular instances to general rules, so as to enable the scholar as to gather for himself the. relles ( of leccidence or syntax) from concreté examples. (3) 113 The teaching (3) Again, the new world not proced Om Knam In the Krum of speech and thought into the unknown, which bhinese boys here fject-lessons Cure Fre are plunged in this School is not sufficiently linked with that Chinese old-world life from which these boys emerge - passing from a three years' course of purely bhmese schooling into this English botlege. to me to read (4) Owing to the total and incomprehensible absence of object lessons, the Chinese boys are throughout the School taught: and write English before- they are taught to speak English, to learn words before. they learn the by those words. (5) t thing s denoted But a fundamental The masters hindrance to progress, QUE NO freedom atter, of car de that
2026-05-27 04:10:09 · Baseline
View content

a

mastery of which is pre- supposed

in the school books

rain

remar

used in this bollege, virtually sealed mysteries to these Chinese boys. An attempt has

lately been made to

introduce an

and

Anglo-Chinese conversational phrase book- compiled by one of the masters. The idea deserves the highest praise, but vocabulary phrases are here pect to - her in a haphaz gether bort of way, there being attempt made to lead in the scholars, inductively, Hamilton, Prendergast or even Ollendorff do, from particular instances to general rules, so as to enable the scholar

as

to gather for himself the. relles ( of leccidence or syntax) from concreté examples.

(3)

113

The teaching (3) Again, the new world

not proced

Om Knam

In the Krum of speech and thought into the unknown, which bhinese boys

here fject-lessons

Cure Fre

are

plunged in this School is not sufficiently linked with that Chinese old-world life from which these boys emerge - passing from a three years' course of purely bhmese schooling into this English botlege.

to me

to read

(4) Owing to the total and incomprehensible absence of object lessons, the Chinese boys are throughout the School taught:

and write English before- they are taught to speak English, to learn words before. they learn the by those words.

(5)

t

thing

s denoted

But a fundamental

The masters hindrance to progress,

QUE NO

freedom atter, of

car de

that

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.